^^
A theory along those lines appeared to be kept in hand by fairfax. Save for a few scant facts which on their own were not incriminating (the odd registration here, incorporation there, application up there), it was entirely circumstantial.
The ethics of such a scheme would obviously be questionable. What I think augers well for the players and staff involved is I don't think they're smart enough to be that stupid.
ASADA is focusing on TB4 simply because it's a clean punch. Its legal status isn't questionable. And they also have the aid of public statements like this: (keep in mind that the burden of proof for WADA is nothing like that of criminal proceedings)
http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-news/t ... 2shhd.html
NM: Thymosin Beta 4 – why was that used in Essendon players given there is an opinion from a doctor or researcher and other scientists that its effects are uncertain? (note: The AFL believes it has a strong circumstantial case that TB-4 was used on players.)
SD: That's not totally true Nick because, with all due respect, right, there is good data – very good data – that supports Thymosin Beta 4 in the immune system.
NM: OK, why give it to all Essendon players if only some of them had colds and flu?
SD: Well, the point is that there is a degree of immunosuppression after a game or a hard training week, right. Often times the ability to back up next week is decreased by the hit on the immune system.
NM: Did you see any indications in Essendon players that it actually helped them?
SD: Well apart from the fact they won 11 out of their first 14, right, and we did regular bloods [blood tests] . . . at the end of the day I was very happy with the science, I was very happy after working a long time in football, right, that there are periods of malaise which are possibly related to sub-clinical flus and sub-clinical colds, right, which can affect performance. When we want to be honest, Nick, how much performance data is there out there on Actovegin [calf's blood extract)]
NM: There's a lot, isn't there?
SD: No there's not! So, you know, you've got to extrapolate from the science.
NM: How often were Essendon players taking Thymosin Beta 4?
SD: [Explains the dosage level but asks that this be not published].
NM: ASADA has just released on its website that Thymosin Beta 4 is prohibited in all routes and out of competition.
SD: Well, that must have just only come in this year and I will get someone to speak to ASADA about that. That's just mind-blowing.
Mind blowing indeed.
BTW worth mentioning at the depths of a cold Canberra Winter. France must be superb right now.